
Ty Manteuffel
9/28/09
Artist Statement for Yum Water!
In my portrayal of a subversive advertisement, I aim to highlight the insincerity behind the bottled water industry. My vision for this piece was inspired by the reality that bottled water is not superior to tap water, however, mainstream media and marketing campaigns lead consumers to believe otherwise. Profit-making campaigns rely heavily on light colors and empty space to give their product a clean and pure feeling. In reality, the bottled water may come from a source no cleaner or more pure than the source of my kitchen sink tap water. The goal in my advertisement is to satirically emphasize and contrast the depictions of water in bottled water advertisements.
In thinking about the essence of my advertisement, I want to play on the sterility of the mainstream bottled water ads by morphing my piece into a dark, contextual contrast. The water in my advertisement is murky in order to further accentuate my theme of uncleanliness. The dirty factory setting expresses my insecurity of where bottled water really comes from. The collage of dilapidated machinery in my piece enhances the uncertainty of the bottling process. I believe my factory portrayal eradicates the sterile, mainstream aesthetic of bottled water and depicts the underlying possibility that it is not as pure as advertised.
The exploration of my subversive advertisement allows me to bring contrast to the forefront and to juxtapose the cleanliness associated with bottled water with the reality of run-down bottling plants. I enjoy using satire as a means of communication in my piece and take pleasure in aligning visual cues with common misconceptions in everyday living. My inspiration for this complex comparison stems from my disgust of advertising plans to exploit the common sense of everyday people. Water is a necessity and not hard to come by, yet consumers are duped into believing bottled water is healthier than drinking from the tap. The consumer buys into the exclusivity of bottled water, when in reality, they are probably not receiving an enhanced product.
Bottled water is being subverted in this ad, based on the dingy factory and the seemingly endless conveyer belt of bottled water. The workers are dressed in heavy work gear that resembles chemical suits.
ReplyDeleteThe goal of this message is to show how buying bottled water is a waste of money, as the water is sometimes not even as good as normal tap water, and that their tap is more expensive and probably less clean.
The most successful aspect of the ad is the placement of the workers, especially the front one, who looks suspiciously at the camera. The factory really makes the company look terrible, which ads to the effect of the ad.
Some improvements on this subvertisement would be better text. I like the tagline in the bottom right corner, but the text up top looks amateur.
1. The product they are subverting is any water bottle company.
ReplyDelete2. The goal of the ad is to have the viewer realize that their tap water is just as good as the bottled water.
3. The most successful aspect of the ad is the placement of the water bottles. For the most part they have correct use of perspective and decrease in a believable size.
4. The front water bottles are a bit off perspective wise. Also, the ad uses 3 different types of font which is distracting. The colors used on the font also make it appear unprofessional... it makes the ad not look really real.
1. Yum Water, the fact that we drink bottled water instead of tap
ReplyDelete2. The workers are in a power plant bottling water that we pay a lot of money for, when we could just be drinking our own water that we already pay for in our water bill.
3. the saturation of the blue and yellow stand out in the "Yum Water". Good color scheme and composition.
4. Ty could have given a little more written text, because I had a somewhat hard time understanding what the ad was about at first glance.
the bottled water industry, where water from taps is sold for more then oil, yet in developed nations is usual worse or the same as normal tap water due to tap water having restraints and bottled water not
ReplyDeletegoal is to hurt the bottled water industry
easily readable text factory line looks dirty and not like something i would want to drink, so that is done well, a visual hierarchy is put onto the 'your water' all other colours have a very dark value so the highlights of the image being the text and then the water draws importance to the target and adds the feeling of filth to the factory
having no visual reference to any in-particular company or an identifying marks makes this more propaganda then a subvertisement, subvertise a company or a campaign
1. This advertisement is subvertising companies that sell bottled water and is also is poking fun at the people who pay extra money to buy bottled water when they can get water from a tap.
ReplyDelete2. The goal of this advertisement is to show that all water comes from a tap whether it is from one's own tap or from a company who bottles the water for the consumer.
3. The contrast that is created between the dark background and the light water bottles is very successful in highlighting the water bottles as being the product in question. Also, the conservative use of color in splotches throughout the piece creates a strong visual pathway from the front-right corner to the back.
4. While there is repetition of the color blue throughout the piece, many of the elements do not seem to be unified together. The font used at the top of the advertisement is a little diffcult to read and is not emphasized enough to be able to compete with the brighter water bottles and company logo that appears in the opposing corner.
The environment of the factory is what strikes me first in this piece. I think the bright colors of the suits works well in the coordination with the logo. The ad is obviously for a water company, depicting the company as a very gritty environment and suggesting that the water they distribute is gross. The most successful element within the ad is the workers in the hazard suits. This gives the viewer a clear message of danger. If you were to rework this piece, I would suggest blurring some of the background images to make the focus look a little more realistic, and possibly work the lighting on the figures to look more natural within the environment. The font at the top is cool but i think you could find one a little more uniform with the logo text. Nicely done.
ReplyDelete1. there is no specific company for this ad, but it is clear they are advertising bottled water
ReplyDelete2. the goal of the ad is to shoe people that when they pay more and drink bottled water, all they are drinking is tap water.
3. the most successful part of the ad i think is the text in the top left because of its color and contrast to the background. it relays the message well so you don't miss it.
4. maybe using a different picture for the background would be better, like something other than a factory. maybe someone drinking from a bottled water.
They are advertising for bottled water
ReplyDeleteThe goal of this ad is to show is to show how we pay for what seems like bottled water but is instead manufacturers just taking water from the tap and bottling it. We think we are drinking purified water, but instead are just drinking from the tap.
The most successful part of this ad is the repetition of bottles of water. The abundance of bottles makes the ad stand out to me. So many bottles are being filled with just simple tap water. I like where the ad is going with this.
The only thing I would do is make the water advertisement specific to one water company
1. bottled water is being subverted here.
ReplyDelete2. the message is that bottled water is a big joke and people are paying for basically the same water they can get out of their own sink.
3. I think this is very clever and well done. I like the lines of text and I think the alignment is very balanced and organized. I like the generic brand name and the generic factory workers, especially because this emphasizes how generic water really is, despite it's fancy labels. I like the yellow/aqua theme because they contrast well with the background image.
4. The only thing I would change about this is the font of the text on the top. I think everything else about the ad looks real except this font choice. I think since there is a fancy font on the bottom right, a more simple font for the top message would like more official.
This ad is subverting bottled water companies. The goal of the piece is to criticize the intent of the company and their advertising scheme with the reality that bottled water might not always be healthy. The repetition of the water bottles is the most successful aspect of the piece. It really emphasizes on the message along with the powerful imagery in the background. The perspective of the water bottles on the assembly line is also very effective and realistic. The depth of each bottle could be emphasized on and made more dramatic with shading. Adding some value to the bottles would also help them contrast with one another. The top header is a little hard to read and doesn't balance with the logo as well as it could. If the lettering was made a little thicker, I think it would balance and cause the header to flow into the header better.
ReplyDelete'' flow into the Logo better.
ReplyDeleteBottled Water
ReplyDeleteThe message of the ad is that bottled water is no better than water that one can get at home--or if anything it is actually worse. The dingy factory and what looks to be something growing in the bottles of water drive home the idea that the text implies.
The most successful part of this ad is the background and the factory itself--as well as the workers in their suits. Everything is well placed and blended so that it does not look like it would not be in the factory. Since they look old and dingy the idea of it not being any better than what you can get at home is really clear.
the only suggestion i have is that the water bottles are a little pixelated when enlarged.
1. Bottled Water Companies
ReplyDelete2. Water that we buy is pretty much the same as the water that we can get for free.
3. The ad is balanced because of the words on the top left and bottom right. A lot of repetition of the water bottles to show just how much of it is being sold.
4. The color of the text should be changed. Looking at that text makes my eyes hurt.
1) Bottled water
ReplyDelete2) The message is to show how bottled water isn't any better than water from the tap.
3) What really works well here is the use of colors such as blue and yellow which really goes together. The use of repitition really does well with rows and rows of water that doesn't look that clean.
4)What I think could be improved on would the make the text on the top more simple and try and stray away from too much photoshop filters. Perhaps make the text a bit less 3d-ish. The logo is fine, but perhaps make the outlines on the "yum" not blend too much with the letters and make them a bit darker. Overall, looks good.
1) bottled water
ReplyDelete2) its suppose to suggest that maybe not all bottled water is is as good for you as t would sem if its made in a old and run down factory.
3) what brings out the message being presented is the nasty factor background . it looks rusted and grime and stuff is os on the machines. the men are wharing safety suits from he water and factory conditions as well. the dark and grimy colors give it this feel.
4) the background i feel distracts the viewer a little too much. maybe put the image in half of he piece and the text in a solid color background.