

Being a hiker I have found that the majority of other hikers involved in the activity today are more concerned with the gear they can get and use to hike than they are with the environment. Commonly called the “leave no trace” ideology, the statement “take only pictures, leave only foot prints” is a saying very popular among hikers, campers, and outdoors men alike but it seems that today we are more concerned with who has the best gear than the places that provide us with the beautiful settings we seek. Having technology so easily accessible in daily life has leaked over into our recreational lives to the point where a backpacker or hiker would not be caught dead without their GPS but rarely has a paper map on them. GPS makers--originally targeting driving navigation--have picked up on this want of the outdoorsmen to have one with them and be able to use it in their outdoor adventures. Thus we have Topographic map software and GPS’s with protective layers in “earth tones” to appeal to the hiker and outdoorsmen. With these new things available the advertisers now target the outdoorsmen in our outdoor magazines and websites.
For this project I found a GPS ad targeting hikers and used the ad to show my dislike of technology interfering with nature. The original ad being for a “Deplore Earthmate GPS” states that the unit is “Waterproof and Impact-Resistant, Perfect for your next hike” showing not only the GPS system but also the Topo Map Software box as well--with one you need the other. I worked off the ad and switched the text to read “The Original Navigation System” and wrote “Foolproof and Reliable, Perfect for the real hiker” and used images of national geographic maps—also topographic--and a compass. Playing off the fact that for so long we have been able to hike with only a compass and a map, now the average hiker believes that he needs a computer along with him. Keeping the background like the original ad but using a graphic of wood behind the green color creates that same texture as was in the background of the original ad but gives it a natural, organic feel verses a computer generated look and also keeps the two comparable side by side. Also the text is about the same style and color linking my subertisement back to the original ad.
It is easy to forget why a hiker hikes and in the outdoors anything can happen where one would need to be able to figure out how to save themselves. Having a general knowledge of the essentials when hiking—like using a compass and reading a map—and not just being able to turn on a GPS are very important. Any average Joe can buy a GPS and go for a hike, but when that GPS’s batteries die or it crashes he may not be able to find his way back. The cause of the majority of accidents in nature is people not being prepared and knowledgeable in basic safety when in the wild and the current technology hinders anyone from learning those basic skills. So why have technology in nature? Aren’t we going into the wild to leave all of that behind?
1. Technology
ReplyDelete2. Seems like people cant do anything with out technology these days. They need exact information where they are and where they are going. People were doing just that for thousands of years prior to the creating of technology.
3. The flow goes from upper left to bottom right, so it becomes easy to read and get the message. Some empty space on the left but your eyes dont go their because of the flow.
4. Changing he background color would have helped because the green on the map blends in with the background, so it seems like words are floating. the string on the compass is cut off so its purpose is questioned, you could have just edited it so it goes off the page.
This advertisement is a parody of navigation and GPS systems. Its goal is to show how the old fashion way of using a compass is more effective than using a computerized system that does all the work for an individual. The most successful aspect of the piece is the contrast of the text with the textured background. The coloring goes with the theme of nature and symbolizes what the theme of the ad's message. The sharp horizontal and vertical alignment of some objects, such as the compass, takes away from the piece. If the compass helped create some depth by moving into the background with the use of a perspective point, it would help the flow of the aid as well as the emphasis on the objects.
ReplyDelete1) GPS/ road maps
ReplyDelete2) I'm gonna shoot and say this ad is about how people have become so fixed on things like GPS and online maps searches that they cant navigate by use of a map anymore. It's telling that people need to start looking at maps again and learn how to navigate the roads and trials again with GPS. It also stating that using fancy GPS takes away from the traditional hiking tradition and makes it something less adventurous.
3) I like the feel of the piece and how it makes it seem its like on a paper map you would read or see. he old illustrated maps and compass are classic tools of hiking and draw emphasis from the viewer. it goes along well with the green background as the dark color makes the white and yellow pop out more.
4) I think of adding some more shapes and such that could resemble the layout that is seen on the maps in the picture. It will give it a more traditional look and feel like the ad itself is a map as o what the viewer is supposed to do.
Technology
ReplyDeleteThe idea is that technology has taken over our world. So many people are lost without it. This ad is showing how society used to function without it, and that there was still success. It's making fun of all the new gadgets people so desperately rely on.
The most successful aspect of this ad is the large font because it right away tells the viewer what the product is. The balance is a little of because there is a blank green space in the lower left with nothing there.
I would suggest to balance the piece a little better and to use a different color background so that the National Geographic booklets don't blend in with the background so much.
1. this is mocking modern technology, specifically gps.
ReplyDelete2. this is making fun of people who have fancy navigating systems and suggesting the old fashion way is the best way to go.
3. The big white font contrasts nicely with the green, the green is a good choice because it reminds the viewer of nature. I like that the images speak for themselves, rather than the text telling you what the ad is talking about.
4. I think there are alignment and spacing issues here, the tops of the maps are very close to the writing, the writing is awkwardly spaced out, and there is a lot of empty space on the bottom left half of the page. I also would have liked to see a stronger font choice, because the font used reminds me of microsoft word which makes it seem less professional.
1. The ad is subverting the use of a gps system to find your way. It is mocking people who use it.
ReplyDelete2. The message is saying that a "real" hiker doesn't need to use a gps system... they should be able to read a map.
3. The text and images create a balance to the ad. I also like the message. The "leave your gps at home" text is smaller and is very blunt. The white text against the background also brings the viewers attention straight to it as it is very striking.
4. I would like to see the compass incorporated more with the maps. It would be nice if it were placed in the spread formation along with the maps.
Melissa is subverting technology and it's impact on society today.
ReplyDeleteIt seems like people today can't go anywhere without a GPS or cell phone, what happened to good old compasses and maps?
I think she uses a nice color selection, the green goes well with the maps and outdoorsy feel. The flow of the ad goes from top left corner down to the bottom right corner. The text really pops out at first glance and the images come second.
I think Melissa could fill the negative space in the bottom left. She could also try using a different text, and maybe something to separate the images from the green background. It feels a little unprofessional and boring.
1)GPSs
ReplyDelete2) That people rely on GPSs too much to get to one place or another rather than relying on maps (which usually have more trails on them) for hiking.
3)The use of proportion on the text, the main text bigger than the one below. The overall flow is good, the eye is directly attracted to the big letters on the top page and then goes to the maps on the bottom. The text and the maps contrast will with the background which is a textured green of a mountain image.
4) The lower left corner looks a bit too empty to me, perhaps ad more maps or something or move the existing maps to the left a bit.
The text placement seems a bit strange, perhaps move the "navigation system" a bit to the left as well.
This ad is subverting GPS Navigation and how it is superfluous when you could just use a map.
ReplyDeleteThe message is saying that maps are for real hikers, and those with the cognitive ability to decipher a map show true intellect and commitment to their hobby. GPS is a ridiculous electronic that is being used entirely out of its element. If you need a small electronic to guide you on your hike, why not just stay home and watch it on TV?
The most successful aspect of this ad I think is the concept. It was a good idea subverting something so obvious, but did it in a clever way by paralleling it with maps - an almost archaic technology. The placement of the text, and its size, are also well done. It is loud and distracting - exactly what it should be.
Some improvements would just be general changes in composition. There really isn't much in the ad, and the simplicity is nice, but the green background is extremely uninteresting.
anti GPS/ gadgets in the woods
ReplyDeletebring you back to the simpler time, clean real out door experience
i like the whay the text is spread out and the words them selves work alright although the gps comment is very hidden.
first off the background is very flat, i see something there but it adds no depth so its very flat to me. the majority of the hikers and frankly tourist in outdoors men's clothing probably would find a compass very un-reliable. orientation with maps as well as simple things like headings need to be trained something the weekend out doors men dont always get although the BEST part is it will get more of those people lost in the woods, they want to pretend to play outdoors men, let them
but ya a map and a compass is the way to go, game boy and e-mail in your pocket take away from nature so much
1. The product being subverted is modern technology, specifically the GPS.
ReplyDelete2. The goal of the image is to show how technology has made superficial advances as it finds solutions for products that already exist and work.
3. The simplicity of the piece really creates a unique flow through the text, creating emphasis on the subject matter.
4. The texture of the background could have been exemplified a little better. This would help to add more depth to the piece.
1.)The ad is subverting GPS units, while making fun of the general public. I get the feeling that the ad is telling us that we have grown to stupid o read a simple map.
ReplyDelete2.)The message of the ad is that we do not need a fancy piece of technology to tell us how to get somewhere and that people have gotten lazy as a result of advancements in technology
3.)The most successful part of the ad has to be the balance of the composition and the text is very necessary in portraying the message.
1. Subverting our cultures reliance on technology for everything.
ReplyDelete2. The message is that as a culture we are so reliant on technology that we do not know or use basic skills like how to use a map.
3. It really reminds me of an advertisement that would appear in Backpacker Magazine or National Geographic because of the font and background. The message is very direct and clear.
4. The blank space of the left corner is really blank. Rather than being a successful use of negative space, the bottom half of the composition just does not look balanced. Also, the maps touch the words which is really distracting to me as a viewer. Maybe if the maps were a little smaller that would not be an issue.
1. this ad is subvertising GPS technology.
ReplyDelete2. the message is that you don't really need a whole GS system and technology when you are on a hike. a map and compass should be able to guide you just as well.
3. the most successful part of the ad i would say would be the green background. it creates a good feeling of nature. i think the empty space works next to the maps and compass because it creates a focal point on them. the text is simple and easy to read, and the different sizes emphasize different aspects well.
4. a suggestion would be to integrate your message a little more strongly. the GPS sentence is very small so it took me a little longer than i would have liked to understand the ad's meaning.